Logic problems: 11 Plus verbal reasoning practice

Put people in order from clues, then answer a question.

OftenIn many papers, especially GL AssessmentAbout 35 seconds a question in the test

The big idea

Logic questions give a few clues, such as “Ada is taller than Ben”. Write the names in a line from tallest to shortest as you read each clue, then answer the question from your line.

Tips that save marks

  • Turn “shorter than” round: “Ben is shorter than Ada” means Ada is taller than Ben.
  • Draw a quick line or ladder: it is faster than keeping it in your head.
  • Check the question: tallest, shortest or second tallest?

Now try five

Try each one before you look at the answer: answering from memory is what makes it stick. Tap an option to check it. Most children get three or four right at first; five out of five means move on to the next topic.

Question 1Aim for about 35 seconds

Read the clues. One of them could be left out and you could still put everyone in order from tallest to shortest. Which clue?

  1. Esme is taller than Jude.
  2. Gita is taller than Esme.
  3. Jude is taller than Hal.
  4. Gita is taller than Hal.
Show the worked answer

Answer: C, Gita is taller than Hal.

How to work it out

  1. “Gita is taller than Hal.” follows from the other clues (the order is Gita, Esme, Jude, Hal from tallest to shortest).
  2. Each of the others, left out, leaves more than one possible order.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A (None: every clue is needed): Leaving out “Gita is taller than Hal.” still leaves one answer, because it follows from the other clues.
  • B (Esme is taller than Jude.): Nothing else says where Esme stands against Jude: without this clue there would be 5 possible orders, not one.
  • D (Gita is taller than Esme.): Nothing else says where Gita stands against Esme: without this clue there would be 3 possible orders, not one.
  • E (Jude is taller than Hal.): Nothing else says where Jude stands against Hal: without this clue there would be 3 possible orders, not one.
Question 2Aim for about 35 seconds

Dev, Hal, Ben, Esme and Finn each chose a different sport: rounders, hockey, netball, tennis and athletics. Read the clues. Who chose netball?

  1. Esme did not choose netball.
  2. Dev chose neither netball nor tennis.
  3. Hal chose neither netball nor rounders.
  4. Finn chose neither netball nor rounders.
Show the worked answer

Answer: A, Ben

How to work it out

  1. Rule people out one clue at a time: Dev chose neither netball nor tennis; Hal chose neither netball nor rounders; the clue says Esme did not choose netball; Finn chose neither netball nor rounders.
  2. That leaves Ben, who chose netball.

Why the other options are wrong

  • B (Esme): The clue says Esme did not choose netball, so Esme cannot be the one who chose netball.
  • C (Hal): Hal chose neither netball nor rounders, so Hal cannot be the one who chose netball.
  • D (Dev): Dev chose neither netball nor tennis, so Dev cannot be the one who chose netball.
  • E (Finn): Finn chose neither netball nor rounders, so Finn cannot be the one who chose netball.
Question 3Aim for about 35 seconds

Read the clues. Who is the second fastest?

  1. Gita is slower than Hal.
  2. Hal is slower than Ada.
  3. Gita is faster than Esme.
  4. Dev is slower than Esme.
Show the worked answer

Answer: D, Hal

How to work it out

  1. Put the clues in order from fastest to slowest: Ada, Hal, Gita, Esme, Dev.
  2. The second fastest is Hal.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A (Ada): Ada is first from the fastest end, not second. The clues put Hal second.
  • B (Dev): Dev is fifth from the fastest end, not second. The clues put Hal second.
  • C (Esme): Esme is second from the slowest end. The question counts from the fastest end, where Hal is second.
  • E (Gita): Gita is third from the fastest end, not second. The clues put Hal second.
Question 4Aim for about 35 seconds

Sam says: “My three friends all like football. Therefore everyone in the school likes football.” What is wrong with Sam's reasoning?

Show the worked answer

Answer: D, Three friends are far too small and too similar a group to speak for the whole school.

How to work it out

  1. Three friends are far too small and too similar a group to speak for the whole school.
  2. An argument needs true statements and a conclusion that really follows from them; here one of those fails.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A (Football is not popular.): How popular football is does not matter; the reasoning would be weak either way.
  • B (Sam should have asked teachers instead.): Asking a few teachers would be just as small a sample.
  • C (Sam has no friends who like football.): The argument says they do; the problem is how few there are.
  • E (Sam has used the word "therefore" wrongly.): The word is fine; the jump from three people to everyone is the flaw.
Question 5Aim for about 35 seconds

Read the clues. Who is the tallest?

  1. Finn is shorter than Ada.
  2. Ben is taller than Hal.
  3. Cara is shorter than Hal.
  4. Ada is shorter than Cara.
Show the worked answer

Answer: C, Ben

How to work it out

  1. Put the clues in order from tallest to shortest: Ben, Hal, Cara, Ada, Finn.
  2. The tallest is Ben.

Why the other options are wrong

  • A (Hal): Hal is second from the tallest end, in the middle of the line, so is neither the tallest nor the shortest.
  • B (Cara): Cara is third from the tallest end, in the middle of the line, so is neither the tallest nor the shortest.
  • D (Finn): Finn is the shortest, the other end of the line. The question asks for the tallest.
  • E (Ada): Ada is fourth from the tallest end, in the middle of the line, so is neither the tallest nor the shortest.

More verbal reasoning topics

Want a plan built around the topics your child finds hardest?

Practise straight away at your child’s school year in maths and English, with verbal and non-verbal reasoning for the 11 Plus, and every answer explained. A free check, whenever you like, shows what to practise next and builds a weekly plan, for their year or for your target schools. Parents follow progress free.

Try five questions free Start free